2019 · Week 5 · Sep 28, 2019 · Spartan Stadium
Speed4x
View as
Win probability · MSU
modelMSU aheadIU aheadconfidence bandkey playMSU scoreIU score
What if? - hover the chart or a play below, then change how it went
Q2 11:13 · Jake Hartbarger punt for 55 yds for a touchback
Driver values - Δ win prob, pts
Pregame priorHome team on offenseGarbage-time factorScore differentialScore diff ÷ offense timeoutsBlowout margin
This game in five plays
- TD · Q4 14:52: Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Donavan Hale for 12 yds for a TD, (Logan Justus KICK) — IU win probability +21.6 pts (now 51%) (top driver: IU has the ball).
- TD · Q4 12:12: Brian Lewerke pass complete to Matt Seybert for 10 yds for a TD, (Matt Coghlin KICK) — MSU win probability +20.2 pts (now 82%) (top driver: MSU has the ball).
- FG · Q4 3:33: Matt Coghlin 44 yd FG GOOD — MSU win probability +13.5 pts (now 94%) (top driver: MSU has the ball).
- TD · Q4 2:00: Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Whop Philyor for 11 yds for a TD, (Logan Justus KICK) — IU win probability +43.6 pts (now 61%) (top driver: IU has the ball).
- FG · Q4 0:05: Matt Coghlin 21 yd FG GOOD — MSU win probability +28.7 pts (now 95%) (top driver: MSU has the ball).
Was that the right call?
Each option's modeled win probability for the team making the call, from the score, clock and field position before the play. Gaps under one point are close calls. How this works
Fourth downs
MSU made the numbers' call on 7 of 8IU made the numbers' call on 6 of 7
- Q1 15:00MSU 4th & 1 at IU 29, tiedAgrees with the numbersWent for it · 82.7% before the snapGo for itTheir call82.7%71% to convertField goal82.5%−0.258% to makePunt82.2%−0.5average punt
- Q1 11:51MSU 4th & 10 at IU 25, tiedAgrees with the numbersKicked a field goal · 81.9% before the snapGo for it81.8%−<0.128% to convertField goalTheir call81.9%66% to makePunt81.5%−0.4average punt
- Q1 11:51IU 4th & 6 at IU 29, tiedAgrees with the numbersPunted · 18.1% before the snapGo for it18.1%−<0.139% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call18.1%average punt
- Q1 7:59IU 4th & 1 at IU 47, down 7Agrees with the numbersWent for it · 17.9% before the snapGo for itTheir call18.0%70% to convertField goalOut of rangePunt17.8%−0.2average punt
- Q1 4:50MSU 4th & 1 at IU 31, up 7Agrees with the numbersWent for it · 82.3% before the snapGo for itTheir call82.3%71% to convertField goal81.8%−0.554% to makePunt81.6%−0.8average punt
- Q2 12:46IU 4th & 4 at IU 34, down 7Agrees with the numbersPunted · 18.4% before the snapGo for it18.6%−0.148% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call18.7%average punt
- Q2 11:13MSU 4th & 5 at MSU 45, up 7Agrees with the numbersPunted · 81.1% before the snapGo for it81.0%−<0.141% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call81.1%average punt
- Q2 4:00MSU 4th & 14 at MSU 37, tiedAgrees with the numbersPunted · 72.7% before the snapGo for it71.3%−1.418% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call72.8%average punt
- Q2 1:25IU 4th & 5 at IU 18, tiedAgrees with the numbersPunted · 27.9% before the snapGo for it26.5%−1.040% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call27.5%average punt
- Q3 8:23IU 4th & 8 at MSU 8, down 7Agrees with the numbersKicked a field goal · 20.7% before the snapGo for it19.3%−0.726% to convertField goalTheir call20.1%90% to makePunt12.3%−7.8average punt
- Q3 8:17MSU 4th & 3 at IU 46, up 4Close callPunted · 77.7% before the snapGo for it78.5%52% to convertField goal76.0%−2.523% to makePuntTheir call77.6%−1.0average punt
- Q4 14:52MSU 4th & 10 at MSU 25, down 3Agrees with the numbersPunted · 51.9% before the snapGo for it50.7%−3.528% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call54.2%average punt
- Q4 14:16IU 4th & 14 at IU 7, up 3Agrees with the numbersPunted · 44.2% before the snapGo for it39.2%−6.116% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call45.3%average punt
- Q4 12:08IU 4th & 2 at IU 35, down 4Numbers favored go for it by 1.4 ptsPunted · 25.9% before the snapGo for it27.1%57% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call25.7%−1.4average punt
- Q4 3:33MSU 4th & 6 at IU 26, up 4Agrees with the numbersKicked a field goal · 86.5% before the snapGo for it84.2%−0.739% to convertField goalTheir call85.0%64% to makePunt71.7%−13.2average punt
After touchdowns: kick or go for two?
MSU made the numbers' call on 4 of 4IU made the numbers' call on 4 of 4
- Q1 8:04MSU Touchdown, up 6 before the tryAgrees with the numbersKicked · madeKickTheir call82.0%97% to makeGo for two82.0%−<0.145% to convert
- Q1 1:35IU Touchdown, down 1 before the tryAgrees with the numbersKicked · madeKickTheir call21.1%97% to makeGo for two21.1%−<0.145% to convert
- Q2 12:55MSU Touchdown, up 6 before the tryAgrees with the numbersKicked · madeKickTheir call80.7%97% to makeGo for two80.6%−<0.145% to convert
- Q2 4:07IU Touchdown, down 1 before the tryAgrees with the numbersKicked · madeKickTheir call24.5%97% to makeGo for two24.5%−0.145% to convert
- Q2 0:33MSU Touchdown, up 6 before the tryAgrees with the numbersKicked · madeKickTheir call79.7%97% to makeGo for two79.6%−0.145% to convert
- Q4 14:52IU Touchdown, up 2 before the tryAgrees with the numbersKicked · madeKickTheir call45.4%97% to makeGo for two45.1%−0.345% to convert
- Q4 12:12MSU Touchdown, up 3 before the tryAgrees with the numbersKicked · madeKickTheir call75.1%97% to makeGo for two74.8%−0.345% to convert
- Q4 2:00IU Touchdown, down 1 before the tryAgrees with the numbersKicked · madeKickTheir call40.4%97% to makeGo for two38.1%−2.345% to convert
Play by play - hover to pin the curve, click to jump
Download drive chartMSUDrive 1MISSED FG11 plays · 50 yds · 3:0982% → 82%
IUDrive 2PUNT4 plays · 4 yds · 0:0019% → 18%
MSUDrive 3TD7 plays · 71 yds · 2:1181% → 83%
Q1 10:15
1ST & 10
OWN 29
+11
81.2%
Brian Lewerke pass complete to C.J. Hayes for 11 yds to the MchSt 40 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q1 10:15
2ND & 8
OWN 42
+8
81.3%
Brian Lewerke pass complete to Matt Seybert for 8 yds to the 50 yard line for a 1ST downSimilar
Q1 10:15
1ST & 10
50
+30
81.4%
Brian Lewerke pass complete to Cody White for 30 yds to the Ind 20 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q1 10:15
2ND & 9
OPP 19
+15
81.6%
Lewerke, Brian pass incomplete to Gillison, Trenton, PENALTY IND pass interference 15 yards to the IND4, 1ST DOWN MSU, NO PLAY.Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
IUDrive 4DOWNS10 plays · 13 yds · 0:0018% → 18%
Q1 7:59
2ND & 9
OWN 28
+8
82.1%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Stevie Scott III for 8 yds to the Ind 36Similar
Q1 7:59
2ND & 10
OWN 38
+3
82.0%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Whop Philyor for 3 yds to the Ind 41Similar
Q1 7:59
3RD & 7
OWN 41
+6
82.0%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Whop Philyor for 6 yds to the Ind 47Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 5DOWNS4 plays · 8 yds · 0:0083% → 82%
Q1 4:50
2ND & 8
OPP 38
+7
82.7%
Brian Lewerke pass complete to Matt Dotson for 7 yds to the Ind 31Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
IUDrive 6TD6 plays · 68 yds · 2:0418% → 23%
Q1 3:39
2ND & 3
OPP 42
+16
81.0%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Ty Fryfogle for 16 yds to the MchSt 26 for a 1ST down MICHIGAN ST Penalty, offside defense ( Yards) declined for a 1ST downSimilar
Q1 3:39
2ND & 12
OPP 28
0
80.8%
Michael Penix Jr. pass incomplete to Stevie Scott III, broken up by Josh ButlerSimilar
Q1 1:35
3RD & 12
OPP 28
+28
77.3%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Whop Philyor for 28 yds for a TD, (Logan Justus KICK)Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 7TD12 plays · 75 yds · 3:4079% → 83%
Q1 1:35
2ND & 15
OWN 20
+7
78.8%
Brian Lewerke pass complete to Darrell Stewart Jr. for 7 yds to the MchSt 27Similar
Q1 1:35
3RD & 8
OWN 27
+20
78.5%
Brian Lewerke pass complete to C.J. Hayes for 20 yds to the MchSt 47 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q2 15:00
1ST & 10
OWN 47
+35
79.3%
Brian Lewerke pass complete to Darrell Stewart Jr. for 35 yds to the Ind 18 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q2 15:00
3RD & 9
OPP 17
+12
79.4%
Brian Lewerke pass complete to Cody White for 12 yds to the Ind 5 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q2 15:00
1ST & GOAL
OPP 5
0
79.9%
Brian Lewerke pass incomplete to Darrell Stewart Jr., broken up by Tiawan MullenSimilar
Q2 15:00
2ND & GOAL
OPP 5
0
79.9%
Brian Lewerke pass incomplete to Darrell Stewart Jr., broken up by Tiawan MullenSimilar
Q2 12:55
3RD & GOAL
OPP 5
+5
82.6%
Brian Lewerke pass complete to Darrell Stewart Jr. for 5 yds for a TD, (Matt Coghlin KICK)Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
IUDrive 8PUNT5 plays · 6 yds · 0:0019% → 18%
Q2 12:46
2ND & 8
OWN 30
+4
81.4%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Stevie Scott III for 4 yds to the Ind 34Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 9PUNT6 plays · 17 yds · 0:0082% → 82%
IUDrive 10TD14 plays · 80 yds · 5:3818% → 32%
Q2 9:45
1ST & 10
OWN 20
+5
81.6%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Whop Philyor for 5 yds to the Ind 25Similar
Q2 9:45
2ND & 5
OWN 25
+9
81.3%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Whop Philyor for 9 yds to the Ind 34 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q2 9:45
2ND & 8
OWN 36
+5
81.1%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Peyton Hendershot for 5 yds to the Ind 41Similar
Q2 9:45
3RD & 3
OWN 41
+10
80.7%
Penix Jr., Michael pass complete to Hale, Donavan for 7 yards to the IND48 (Butler, Josh), PENALTY MSU holding 10 yards to the MSU49, 1ST DOWN IND, NO PLAY.Similar
Q2 9:45
1ST & 10
OPP 49
+16
80.2%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Donavan Hale for 16 yds to the MchSt 33 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q2 9:45
1ST & 10
OPP 33
+28
79.6%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Donavan Hale for 28 yds to the MchSt 5 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q2 6:17
2ND & GOAL
OPP 4
-10
78.6%
Penix Jr., Michael pass incomplete to Westbrook, Nick, PENALTY IND holding 10 yards to the MSU14, NO PLAY.Similar
Q2 6:17
2ND & GOAL
OPP 14
+7
79.6%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Donavan Hale for 7 yds to the MchSt 7Similar
Q2 6:17
3RD & GOAL
OPP 7
+5
79.6%
Penix Jr., Michael pass incomplete to Westbrook, Nick, PENALTY MSU pass interference 5 yards to the MSU2, 1ST DOWN IND, NO PLAY.Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 11PUNT8 plays · 7 yds · 0:0074% → 73%
Q2 4:00
4TH & 14
OWN 37
+10
72.6%
Jake Hartbarger punt for 60 yds , Whop Philyor returns for 10 yds to the Ind 13Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
IUDrive 12PUNT6 plays · 5 yds · 0:4830% → 29%
Q2 2:13
2ND & 12
OWN 11
+3
70.5%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Peyton Hendershot for 3 yds to the Ind 14Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 13TD6 plays · 56 yds · 0:4674% → 84%
Q2 1:19
1ST & 10
OWN 44
+9
74.1%
Brian Lewerke pass complete to Cody White for 9 yds to the Ind 47Similar
Q2 1:19
2ND & 10
OPP 42
+16
74.7%
Brian Lewerke pass complete to Cody White for 16 yds to the Ind 26 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q2 0:33
1ST & 10
OPP 26
+26
84.2%
Brian Lewerke pass complete to Darrell Stewart Jr. for 26 yds for a TD, (Matt Coghlin KICK)Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
IUDrive 14END OF HALF2 plays · -2 yds · 0:0018% → 18%
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
IUDrive 15FG14 plays · 81 yds · 6:3219% → 23%
Q3 14:55
2ND & 8
OWN 13
+9
80.8%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Whop Philyor for 9 yds to the Ind 22 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q3 14:55
2ND & 4
OWN 28
+13
79.9%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Stevie Scott III for 13 yds to the Ind 41 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q3 14:55
1ST & 10
OWN 41
+11
79.4%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Whop Philyor for 11 yds to the MchSt 48 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q3 14:55
1ST & 10
OPP 48
+25
78.4%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Whop Philyor for 25 yds to the MchSt 23 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q3 14:55
1ST & 10
OPP 23
+5
77.0%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Nick Westbrook for 5 yds to the MchSt 18Similar
Q3 14:55
2ND & 5
OPP 18
+8
77.0%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Ty Fryfogle for 8 yds to the MchSt 10 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q3 14:55
1ST & GOAL
OPP 10
+3
77.0%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Stevie Scott III for 3 yds to the MchSt 7Similar
Q3 9:06
3RD & GOAL
OPP 8
0
78.9%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Whop Philyor for no gain to the MchSt 8Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 16PUNT6 plays · 26 yds · 0:0078% → 79%
Q3 8:17
3RD & 3
OPP 46
0
79.7%
Brian Lewerke pass incomplete to Cody White MICHIGAN ST Penalty, illegal motion ( Yards) declinedSimilar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
IUDrive 17TD13 plays · 80 yds · 6:3622% → 51%
Q3 6:28
1ST & 10
OWN 32
+3
76.8%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Nick Westbrook for 3 yds to the Ind 35Similar
Q3 6:28
1ST & 10
OWN 47
+18
74.8%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Donavan Hale for 18 yds to the MchSt 35 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q3 6:28
2ND & 11
OPP 36
+12
74.5%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Whop Philyor for 12 yds to the MchSt 24 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q3 6:28
1ST & 10
OPP 24
+7
72.9%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to David Ellis for 7 yds to the MchSt 17Similar
Q3 6:28
1ST & 10
OPP 13
+1
72.9%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Ty Fryfogle for 1 yd to the MchSt 12Similar
Q4 15:00
2ND & 9
OPP 12
0
70.6%
Michael Penix Jr. pass incomplete to Ty Fryfogle, broken up by Josh ButlerSimilar
Q4 14:52
3RD & 9
OPP 12
+12
49.0%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Donavan Hale for 12 yds for a TD, (Logan Justus KICK)Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 18PUNT5 plays · 0 yds · 0:0056% → 53%
Q4 14:52
3RD & 10
OWN 25
0
54.2%
Brian Lewerke pass incomplete to Darrell Stewart Jr., broken up by Tiawan MullenSimilar
Q4 14:52
4TH & 10
OWN 25
+2
53.1%
Jake Hartbarger punt for 56 yds , Whop Philyor returns for 2 yds to the Ind 27 INDIANA Penalty, Offensive holding (10 Yards) to the Ind 11Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
IUDrive 19PUNT4 plays · -4 yds · 0:0048% → 43%
Q4 14:16
3RD & 8
OWN 13
-6
54.1%
Michael Penix Jr. sacked by Raequan Williams for a loss of 6 yards to the Ind 7Similar
Q4 14:16
4TH & 14
OWN 7
+22
56.7%
Haydon Whitehead punt for 46 yds , Brandon Sowards returns for 22 yds to the Ind 29 INDIANA Penalty, illegal motion (-5 Yards) to the Ind 26Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 20TD2 plays · 26 yds · 0:3062% → 82%
IUDrive 21PUNT5 plays · 8 yds · 0:0024% → 24%
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 22FG14 plays · 54 yds · 6:2577% → 94%
Q4 9:58
3RD & 4
OWN 26
+7
76.1%
Brian Lewerke pass complete to C.J. Hayes for 7 yds to the MchSt 33 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q4 9:58
3RD & 8
OWN 46
+10
77.2%
Lewerke, Brian sacked for loss of 1 yard to the MSU45 (Ziemba, Michael), fumble by Lewerke, Brian recovered by IND Nofoagatoto'a, Sio at MSU45, PENALTY IND holding 10 yards to the IND44, 1ST DOWN MSU, NO PLAY.Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
IUDrive 23TD11 plays · 78 yds · 1:2710% → 61%
Q4 3:27
2ND & 10
OWN 22
+15
90.0%
Penix Jr., Michael pass incomplete to Hale, Donavan, PENALTY MSU pass interference 15 yards to the IND37, 1ST DOWN IND, NO PLAY.Similar
Q4 3:27
3RD & 10
OWN 47
+12
88.6%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Donavan Hale for 12 yds to the MchSt 41 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q4 3:27
1ST & 10
OPP 41
+19
86.4%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Whop Philyor for 19 yds to the MchSt 22 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q4 2:09
1ST & 10
OPP 22
+11
82.7%
Penix Jr., Michael pass incomplete to Westbrook, Nick, PENALTY MSU roughing passer 11 yards to the MSU11, 1ST DOWN IND, NO PLAY.Similar
Q4 2:00
1ST & 10
OPP 11
+11
39.1%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Whop Philyor for 11 yds for a TD, (Logan Justus KICK)Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 24FG11 plays · 72 yds · 1:5557% → 94%
Q4 2:00
1ST & 10
OWN 25
+44
56.9%
Brian Lewerke pass complete to Darrell Stewart Jr. for 44 yds to the Ind 31 for a 1ST downSimilar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
IUDrive 25FUMBLE TD2 plays · -25 yds · 0:003% → 3%
Q4 0:00
1ST & 10
OWN 25
0
96.9%
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Donavan Hale for 6 yds lat. to Nick Westbrook for a loss of 5 yards lat. to Michael Penix Jr. for a loss of 18 yards for a TD Michael Penix Jr. fumbled, recovered by MchSt Michael Dowell for a TDSimilar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
Biggest swings
TD · Q4 2:00
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Whop Philyor for 11 yds for a TD, (Logan Justus KICK)
-43.6
FG · Q4 0:05
Matt Coghlin 21 yd FG GOOD
+28.7
TD · Q4 14:52
Michael Penix Jr. pass complete to Donavan Hale for 12 yds for a TD, (Logan Justus KICK)
-21.6