2016 · Week 3 · Sep 17, 2016 · Notre Dame Stadium
Speed4x
View as
Win probability · ND
modelND aheadMSU aheadconfidence bandkey playND scoreMSU score
What if? - hover the chart or a play below, then change how it went
Q4 0:00 · TEAM run for a loss of 2 yards to the NDame 27
Driver values - Δ win prob, pts
Home team on offensePregame priorScore differentialGarbage-time factorScore diff ÷ offense timeoutsScore diff ÷ seconds remaining
This game in five plays
- TD · Q2 9:30: Donnie Corley 38 Yd pass from Tyler O'Connor (Matt Macksood Pass to Josiah Price for Two-Point Conversion) — MSU win probability +11.6 pts (now 37%) (top driver: MSU has the ball).
- TD · Q3 7:48: Gerald Holmes 3 Yd Run (Michael Geiger Kick) — MSU win probability +15.9 pts (now 79%) (top driver: MSU has the ball).
- TD · Q3 6:28: LJ Scott 9 Yd Run (Michael Geiger Kick) — MSU win probability +14.3 pts (now 94%) (top driver: MSU has the ball).
- TD · Q4 11:45: DeShone Kizer 3 Yd Run (Justin Yoon Kick) — ND win probability +15.2 pts (now 19%) (top driver: ND has the ball).
- TD · Q4 6:02: Durham Smythe 12 Yd pass from DeShone Kizer (Justin Yoon Kick) — ND win probability +15.2 pts (now 24%) (top driver: ND has the ball).
Was that the right call?
Each option's modeled win probability for the team making the call, from the score, clock and field position before the play. Gaps under one point are close calls. How this works
Fourth downs
ND made the numbers' call on 5 of 7MSU made the numbers' call on 4 of 8
- Q1 13:10ND 4th & 10 at ND 41, tiedAgrees with the numbersPunted · 68.9% before the snapGo for it68.9%−0.129% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call69.0%average punt
- Q1 10:27MSU 4th & 1 at MSU 44, tiedAgrees with the numbersWent for it · 31.6% before the snapGo for itTheir call31.6%70% to convertField goalOut of rangePunt31.5%−0.1average punt
- Q1 7:31MSU 4th & 6 at ND 39, tiedClose callPunted · 32.3% before the snapGo for it32.4%40% to convertField goal32.2%−0.236% to makePuntTheir call32.3%−0.1average punt
- Q2 11:59ND 4th & 12 at ND 31, up 7Agrees with the numbersPunted · 71.1% before the snapGo for it70.4%−1.322% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call71.7%average punt
- Q2 9:38MSU 4th & 4 at MSU 18, down 7Close callPunted · 26.6% before the snapGo for it26.3%47% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call26.3%−0.1average punt
- Q2 8:11MSU 4th & 5 at ND 39, up 1Close callPunted · 38.5% before the snapGo for it38.6%42% to convertField goal37.8%−0.936% to makePuntTheir call37.8%−0.8average punt
- Q2 5:06ND 4th & 1 at ND 21, down 1Numbers favored go for it by 1.2 ptsPunted · 60.8% before the snapGo for it61.3%71% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call60.1%−1.2average punt
- Q3 14:09MSU 4th & 10 at MSU 25, up 8Agrees with the numbersPunted · 54.0% before the snapGo for it53.2%−1.828% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call55.0%average punt
- Q3 12:41ND 4th & 12 at ND 38, down 8Agrees with the numbersPunted · 42.6% before the snapGo for it41.4%−2.023% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call43.4%average punt
- Q3 4:26ND 4th & 6 at ND 30, down 22Agrees with the numbersPunted · 7.8% before the snapGo for it8.3%−0.639% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call8.9%average punt
- Q4 14:08MSU 4th & 3 at MSU 44, up 22Close callPunted · 96.0% before the snapGo for it96.3%52% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call96.1%−0.2average punt
- Q4 12:02ND 4th & 1 at MSU 4, down 22Agrees with the numbersWent for it · 4.0% before the snapGo for itTheir call3.7%65% to convertField goal2.2%−1.593% to makePunt-2.5%−6.2average punt
- Q4 7:47MSU 4th & 12 at MSU 31, up 15Agrees with the numbersPunted · 93.3% before the snapGo for it92.3%−1.822% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call94.1%average punt
- Q4 4:18MSU 4th & 5 at MSU 35, up 8Agrees with the numbersPunted · 88.8% before the snapGo for it88.4%−0.841% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call89.2%average punt
- Q4 3:30ND 4th & 7 at ND 32, down 8Close callPunted · 12.8% before the snapGo for it10.5%36% to convertField goalOut of rangePuntTheir call9.9%−0.6average punt
After touchdowns: kick or go for two?
ND made the numbers' call on 2 of 4MSU made the numbers' call on 4 of 5
- Q1 3:07ND Touchdown, up 6 before the tryAgrees with the numbersKicked · madeKickTheir call70.7%97% to makeGo for two70.6%−<0.145% to convert
- Q2 9:30MSU Touchdown, down 1 before the tryClose callWent for two · convertedKick33.0%97% to makeGo for twoTheir call32.9%−<0.145% to convert
- Q2 0:23MSU Touchdown, up 7 before the tryAgrees with the numbersKicked · madeKickTheir call52.2%97% to makeGo for two52.1%−0.245% to convert
- Q3 7:48MSU Touchdown, up 14 before the tryAgrees with the numbersKicked · madeKickTheir call74.7%97% to makeGo for two74.6%−0.145% to convert
- Q3 6:28MSU Touchdown, up 21 before the tryAgrees with the numbersKicked · madeKickTheir call91.2%97% to makeGo for two91.0%−0.145% to convert
- Q3 3:45MSU Touchdown, up 28 before the tryAgrees with the numbersKicked · madeKickTheir call97.7%97% to makeGo for two97.7%−<0.145% to convert
- Q3 2:40ND Touchdown, down 23 before the tryAgrees with the numbersKicked · madeKickTheir call5.6%97% to makeGo for two5.5%−0.145% to convert
- Q4 11:45ND Touchdown, down 16 before the tryClose callKicked · madeKickTheir call9.9%−<0.197% to makeGo for two9.9%45% to convert
- Q4 6:02ND Touchdown, down 9 before the tryNumbers favored go for two by 2.4 ptsKicked · madeKickTheir call13.5%−2.497% to makeGo for two15.9%45% to convert
Play by play - hover to pin the curve, click to jump
Download drive chartNDDrive 1PUNT8 plays · 31 yds · 1:1472% → 72%
Q1 14:24
1ST & 10
OWN 10
+19
72.1%
DeShone Kizer pass complete to Torii Hunter Jr. for 19 yds to the NDame 29 for a 1ST downSimilar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 2PUNT13 plays · 37 yds · 5:2428% → 30%
Q1 12:55
1ST & 10
OWN 24
+3
71.8%
Tyler O'Connor pass complete to R.J. Shelton for 3 yds to the MchSt 27Similar
Q1 12:16
3RD & 2
OWN 32
+3
71.6%
Tyler O'Connor pass complete to LJ Scott for 3 yds to the MchSt 35 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q1 10:48
3RD & 4
OWN 41
+3
71.1%
Tyler O'Connor pass complete to Prescott Line for 3 yds to the MchSt 44Similar
Q1 8:55
2ND & 8
OWN 48
+9
70.5%
Tyler O'Connor pass complete to R.J. Shelton for 9 yds to the NDame 43 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q1 7:31
4TH & 6
OPP 39
0
70.3%
Jake Hartbarger punt for 30 yds, fair catch by C.J. Sanders at the NDame 9Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
NDDrive 3TD11 plays · 91 yds · 3:4971% → 75%
Q1 6:02
3RD & 8
OWN 11
+9
70.0%
DeShone Kizer pass complete to Corey Holmes for 9 yds to the NDame 20 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q1 5:00
2ND & 6
OWN 24
+48
70.3%
DeShone Kizer pass complete to Equanimeous St. Brown for 48 yds to the MchSt 28 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q1 4:19
1ST & 10
OPP 28
-2
71.3%
DeShone Kizer pass complete to Josh Adams for a loss of 2 yards to the MchSt 30Similar
Q1 4:08
2ND & 12
OPP 30
+15
71.2%
Kizer, DeShone pass incomplete to Sanders, C.J., PENALTY MICHIGANST personal foul 15 yards to the MICHIGANST15, NO PLAY, 1ST DOWN NOTREDAME.Similar
Q1 3:30
1ST & GOAL
OPP 3
-11
71.3%
Tarean Folston run for a loss of 1 yard to the MchSt 4 NOTRE DAME Penalty, Illegal Block (-10 Yards) to the MchSt 14Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 4INT9 plays · 53 yds · 3:3227% → 28%
Q1 1:10
3RD & 8
OWN 27
+16
73.7%
Tyler O'Connor pass complete to R.J. Shelton for 16 yds to the MchSt 43 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q1 0:15
2ND & 8
OWN 45
+33
72.5%
Tyler O'Connor pass complete to Monty Madaris for 33 yds to the NDame 22 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q2 14:28
2ND & 11
OPP 23
+1
71.6%
Tyler O'Connor pass complete to Josiah Price for 1 yd to the NDame 22Similar
Q2 14:05
3RD & 10
OPP 22
+30
72.3%
Tyler O'Connor pass intercepted Devin Studstill return for 30 yds to the NDame 33Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
NDDrive 5PUNT4 plays · -2 yds · 1:3174% → 73%
MSUDrive 6FUMBLE4 plays · 6 yds · 2:1026% → 25%
Q2 9:38
4TH & 4
OWN 18
-2
75.1%
Jake Hartbarger punt for 42 yds , Miles Boykin returns for a loss of 2 yards to the NDame 38 Miles Boykin fumbled, recovered by MchStSimilar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 7TD1 play · 38 yds · 0:0037% → 37%
Q2 9:30
1ST & 10
OPP 38
+38
63.5%
Donnie Corley 38 Yd pass from Tyler O'Connor (Matt Macksood Pass to Josiah Price for Two-Point Conversion)Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
NDDrive 8FUMBLE2 plays · 19 yds · 0:0067% → 67%
Q2 9:19
1ST & 10
OWN 25
+19
66.6%
DeShone Kizer pass complete to C.J. Sanders for 19 yds C.J. Sanders fumbled, recovered by MchStSimilar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 9PUNT5 plays · 5 yds · 0:3437% → 36%
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
NDDrive 10PUNT6 plays · 20 yds · 2:5466% → 64%
Q2 7:20
2ND & 9
OWN 2
+10
65.4%
DeShone Kizer pass complete to Torii Hunter Jr. for 10 yds to the NDame 12 for a 1ST downSimilar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 11TD12 plays · 92 yds · 4:1236% → 57%
Q2 3:20
3RD & 3
OWN 15
+23
63.6%
Tyler O'Connor pass complete to Josiah Price for 23 yds to the MchSt 38 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q2 2:52
1ST & 10
OWN 38
+11
60.7%
Tyler O'Connor pass complete to Donnie Corley for 11 yds to the MchSt 49 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q2 0:28
1ST & 10
OPP 21
+11
56.7%
Tyler O'Connor pass complete to Donnie Corley for 11 yds to the NDame 10 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q2 0:23
1ST & GOAL
OPP 10
+10
43.2%
R.J. Shelton 10 Yd pass from Tyler O'Connor (Michael Geiger Kick)Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
NDDrive 12END OF HALF5 plays · 25 yds · 0:0948% → 50%
MSUDrive 13PUNT5 plays · 0 yds · 0:4454% → 52%
Q3 14:34
2ND & 10
OWN 25
0
46.3%
Tyler O'Connor pass complete to R.J. Shelton for no gain to the MchSt 25Similar
Q3 14:09
4TH & 10
OWN 25
+3
47.8%
Jake Hartbarger punt for 40 yds , C.J. Sanders returns for 3 yds to the NDame 28 NOTRE DAME Penalty, Unsportsmanlike Conduct (15 Yards) to the NDame 23Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
NDDrive 14PUNT7 plays · 15 yds · 1:0947% → 44%
MSUDrive 15TD12 plays · 75 yds · 4:3456% → 79%
Q3 10:03
3RD & 3
50
+7
40.2%
Tyler O'Connor pass complete to Monty Madaris for 7 yds to the NDame 43 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q3 9:52
1ST & 10
OPP 43
+15
39.2%
O'Connor, Tyler pass incomplete to Shelton, R.J., PENALTY NOTREDAME pass interference 15 yards to the NOTREDAME28, NO PLAY, 1ST DOWN MICHIGANST.Similar
Q3 7:54
2ND & 10
OPP 17
+14
37.0%
Tyler O'Connor pass complete to R.J. Shelton for 14 yds to the NDame 3 for a 1ST downSimilar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
NDDrive 16INT3 plays · 0 yds · 0:1127% → 27%
MSUDrive 17TD3 plays · 39 yds · 0:2279% → 94%
NDDrive 18PUNT5 plays · 4 yds · 1:3610% → 8%
MSUDrive 19TD2 plays · 78 yds · 0:3095% → 97%
NDDrive 20TD5 plays · 65 yds · 0:523% → 8%
MSUDrive 21PUNT8 plays · 19 yds · 3:1196% → 97%
NDDrive 22TD9 plays · 80 yds · 2:054% → 19%
Q4 13:50
1ST & 10
OWN 20
+33
4.0%
DeShone Kizer pass complete to Chase Claypool for 33 yds to the MchSt 47 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q4 13:31
2ND & 10
OPP 47
+34
4.3%
DeShone Kizer pass complete to C.J. Sanders for 34 yds to the MchSt 13 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q4 13:14
1ST & 10
OPP 13
+8
4.8%
DeShone Kizer pass complete to Torii Hunter Jr. for 8 yds to the MchSt 5Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 23PUNT8 plays · 10 yds · 3:4392% → 95%
NDDrive 24TD9 plays · 69 yds · 1:378% → 24%
Q4 7:39
1ST & 10
OWN 31
+15
8.0%
MICHIGAN ST Penalty, Defensive Pass Interference (15 Yards) to the NDame 46 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q4 7:18
1ST & 10
OWN 46
+19
8.2%
DeShone Kizer pass complete to Kevin Stepherson for 19 yds to the MchSt 35 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q4 6:45
3RD & 10
OPP 35
+12
8.5%
DeShone Kizer pass complete to Equanimeous St. Brown for 12 yds to the MchSt 23 for a 1ST downSimilar
Q4 6:33
2ND & 10
OPP 23
+11
9.0%
DeShone Kizer pass complete to Torii Hunter Jr. for 11 yds to the MchSt 12 for a 1ST downSimilar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 25PUNT5 plays · 5 yds · 1:1588% → 88%
Q4 4:18
4TH & 5
OWN 35
+6
11.6%
Jake Hartbarger punt for 42 yds , C.J. Sanders returns for 6 yds to the NDame 29Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
NDDrive 26PUNT5 plays · 3 yds · 0:4215% → 12%
Q4 3:47
2ND & 10
OWN 29
+8
14.0%
DeShone Kizer pass complete to Equanimeous St. Brown for 8 yds to the NDame 37Similar
Q4 3:38
3RD & 2
OWN 37
-5
16.0%
DeShone Kizer sacked by Raequan Williams for a loss of 5 yards to the NDame 32Similar
Q4 3:30
4TH & 7
OWN 32
0
11.9%
Tyler Newsome punt for 54 yds, fair catch by R.J. Shelton at the MchSt 14Similar
own 0own 2550opp 25opp 0
MSUDrive 27END OF GAME9 plays · 59 yds · 3:1192% → 98%
Biggest swings
TD · Q3 7:48
Gerald Holmes 3 Yd Run (Michael Geiger Kick)
-15.9
TD · Q4 11:45
DeShone Kizer 3 Yd Run (Justin Yoon Kick)
+15.2
TD · Q4 6:02
Durham Smythe 12 Yd pass from DeShone Kizer (Justin Yoon Kick)
+15.2